Iran Human RightsStrasbourg Rejects Iranian Assurances Regarding Use of Torture

Strasbourg Rejects Iranian Assurances Regarding Use of Torture

-

The Strasbourg court

By Pooya Stone

Although Iranian authorities provided assurances that he would not be tortured, the European Court of Human Rights has held that the extradition of a man accused of theft to Iran would breach Article 3 of the human rights convention.

The Strasbourg court provides guidance on the kind of assurances required from the state requesting extradition in GS v Bulgaria (application no. 36538/17). It will not allow extradition unless the assurance is both specific and trustworthy. In this case, GS was wanted for theft, but if he was convicted, he was at risk of receiving corporal punishment — seventy-four lashes. The Strasbourg court would not allow extradition, because it labeled this manner of treatment as torture. In accordance with past case law, it found that the possibility of acquittal or the imposition of a different sentence was not sufficient to dispel the real risk of torture.

The key issue was the assurance provided by the Iranian authorities as part of the extradition request. It stated, without elaboration, that the Iranian authorities would not torture the applicant or subject him to inhuman or degrading treatment.

This assurance was rejected by the court because it was not convinced that the Iranian government regards flogging as torture. It ruled:

This assurance cannot be regarded as sufficient, for at least two reasons. First, the extradition request omitted to specify that Article 656 § 4 of the Iranian Penal Code envisaged not only imprisonment but also flogging as a type of punishment. This raises profound misgivings about the Iranian authorities’ trustworthiness in this matter. Secondly, it appears that those authorities do not regard flogging and other forms of corporal punishment as inhuman or degrading. Indeed, they recently publicly stated that they considered flogging as a legitimate form of punishment which has been “interpreted wrongfully, by the West, as … degrading” (see paragraph 47 above). The exact tenor of their assurance in that respect is thus quite uncertain.

The Strasbourg court doubted the genuineness of the assurance. Iran has repeatedly refused to comply with recommendations to remove flogging from its penal code and considers it to be an important part of its legal tradition.

Therefore, the European Court of Human Rights is responding to states with inferior human rights records by demanding higher quality assurances, before it will permit extradition, deportation, or removal. GS v Bulgaria is a reminder that a general statement of intention is not enough — particularly if it is made by a state which has disregarded human rights recommendations in the past.

Latest news

Iranians Don’t Buy Officials’ Publicity Stunts

Studying Iran's rising social situation since the 2009 uprising draws our attention to important achievements. During this period, several nationwide...

Iranian Women Are the Most Affected by Extreme Poverty

Following a gathering of more than 100,000 in Paris on October 17, 1987, to remember the victims of violence,...

One in Three Iranians Live Below the Poverty Line

How much did the minimum intake cover the poverty line in Iran in the 2000s? How much were the...

Future of Iran’s Government at Threat As Crises Worsen

For more than four decades, Iran has had inflation rates in double-digits which have left the country in a...

Iran’s Government Plays Hopscotch With the JCPOA

For about four months, nuclear negotiations over Iran’s nuclear file have been stopped. Meanwhile, with the start of Ebrahim...

FATF Rules for Iranian Government To Remain on Their Blacklist

Following meetings that took place on October 19 – 21, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) has decided to...

Must read

Top cleric says Iran will not heed Security Council demand

Iran Focus: Tehran, Iran, Apr. 28 – Iran’s former...

‘Special groups’ surge in Iraq

UPI: Iranian-backed "special groups" are entering Iraq with greater...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you