Iran General NewsJudge to decide if reporter must testify at trial

Judge to decide if reporter must testify at trial

-

AP: Lawyers for a New York Times reporter argued Thursday that the First Amendment should shield him from having to testify about his sources when prosecutors put a former CIA officer on trial for allegedly leaking classified information about Iran.

The Associated Press

By MATTHEW BARAKAT, Associated Press

ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — Lawyers for a New York Times reporter argued Thursday that the First Amendment should shield him from having to testify about his sources when prosecutors put a former CIA officer on trial for allegedly leaking classified information about Iran.

Only when a journalist’s testimony is absolutely critical to a government’s case can prosecutors subpoena a reporter and require him to testify about anonymous sources, said lawyer Joel Kurtzberg, who represents Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter James Risen.

“A reporter should be the last resort, if even at all, not the first resort” when the government puts on a criminal case, Kurtzberg told U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema.

Prosecutors have subpoenaed Risen to testify at the September trial of Jeffrey Sterling, a former CIA officer from O’Fallon, Mo. The government alleges that Sterling was a key source for a chapter in Risen’s 2006 book “State of War,” which details a botched CIA effort during the Clinton administration, dubbed Operation Merlin, to thwart Iran’s nuclear ambitions by secretly giving the Iranians intentionally flawed blueprints through a Russian intermediary.

Prosecutors on Thursday argued that Risen’s First Amendment rights pale in comparison to the government’s need to prosecute criminals and obtain evidence to which juries are rightfully entitled.

Last year, Brinkema quashed a similar subpoena issued to Risen when the case was in front of a grand jury. She ruled that the government simply didn’t need Risen’s testimony to obtain an indictment in light of other evidence possessed by the government, including phone records showing multiple calls between Risen and Sterling.

But Brinkema acknowledged that as the government’s burden of proof becomes higher at trial, it may be entitled to Risen’s testimony now.

On Thursday, though, Brinkema continued to question whether Risen’s testimony was truly necessary, given the substantial circumstantial evidence already possessed by the government.

Prosecutor William Welch responded that juries are fickle and almost always prefer direct evidence — like that which would be provided by Risen himself — to circumstantial evidence. He cited Casey Anthony’s acquittal Tuesday in Florida on charges of murdering her young daughter as an example of what can go wrong when prosecutors lack direct evidence.

“It’s different for 12 people who don’t study law books,” Welch said. “Trials are not syllogisms but stories that need to be laid out.”

Sterling’s lawyer, Edward MacMahon, has urged the judge to defer any ruling on Risen’s testimony until trial. He argued in court papers that the government is engaging in idle speculation by assuming that any testimony from Risen would bolster its case.

Brinkema did not rule at Thursday’s hearing and said she will issue a written opinion later.

Risen did not attend Thursday’s hearing.

Latest news

 Statistics show that New Year accidents’ deaths in Iran reached 585

Ahmad Shirani, the head of the Information and Traffic Control Center of the Iranian regime’s police, announced that the...

Land Subsidence in Critical Conditions in Isfahan

Mehdi Toghyani, a member of the Iranian regime’s Majlis (parliament), pointed to the occurrence of land subsidence in various...

Iran’s Actual Inflation Rate Higher Than Official Stats

The state-run Donya-e-eqtesad newspaper, in a report analyzing the "general sentiment" regarding inflation in 2023, has stated that households...

Iranian Workers’ Monthly $136 Wages Can’t Cover $500 Expenses

The lives of a significant portion of the Iranian population are marked by uncertainty, largely because the Iranian economy...

Iranian Nurses Earn Twice Their Wages in Ride-Hailing Services

Reza Aryanpour, a member of the regime’s Majlis (parliament) Health and Treatment Commission, highlighted the growing trend of nurses...

Iran: Unprecedented Record of 152 Million Liters of Gasoline Consumption Per Day

On March 19, Iran set a new historical record in gasoline consumption with 152 million liters consumed in one...

Must read

Iran poll challenger accused of ballot fraud

The Guardian: Iran's presidential election was thrown into uncharted...

Blacklist the IRGC to contain Iran

Iran Focus London, 10 Feb - The “golden era” of...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you